Teaching Crisis UK: Is the vocation in jeopardy?

Teaching is as much a respected job as an important one, but are today's UK teachers given the compensation they deserve for filling such an important role in society? While it is true that there are more teachers in the UK than ever before, the demand for more teachers is increasing at an even faster rate, leaving schools in desperate need of staff.

Leaders in the education system are going as far as calling the situation a veritable crisis, and their panic is justified with the start of another academic year just around the corner.

In this article, we'll be having a look at the situation in more detail, including an analysis of the challenges faced by the education sector concerning recruiting and retaining new teachers; additionally, we'll be exploring the possible strategies or solutions that might be able to alleviate some of the problems and revitalise the teaching industry.

By the end of this article, readers should have an improved understanding of the teaching "crisis" and a handle on the measures that could be used to improve the willingness of new teachers to enter and stay in the teaching industry.

Want to give private lessons?

Join the Superprof community and share your knowledge with interested and motivated students.

Create an advert

Challenges in the teaching business

To offer meaningful insight or solutions to the problems the teaching industry faces, we must first understand the problem comprehensively. What problems do UK teachers face, causing them to change careers or avoid teaching as a career altogether?

To begin with, let's look at some context surrounding the economic difficulties faced by the broader community in the UK. Teachers and every profession have suffered ever since the COVID-19 pandemic tragically coincided with the economic gymnastic manoeuvre known as Brexit.

THOUGH DECIDED UPON LONG AGO, the UK's choice to leave the European Union had yet to come into effect until the height of the pandemic.

Whether in favour or against the decision to leave, it was known by most people that there would be moderate to severe economic implications due to the decision. However, the massive disruption caused by the spread of the coronavirus could not have been predicted at the time.

As a result, the UK suffered from the fallout disproportionately to other comparable countries and reached new highs in inflation and resource shortages.

This series of events results in a cost of living crisis, leaving UK citizens with less buying power and more significant expenses. For teachers precisely, whose wages are controlled by government budgets, it's as if they are at the mercy of the health of the country's economy, which has certainly seen better days.

The effect on teachers

With the stagnation of teachers' wages compared to the rampant rise of the price of necessities, it's easy to understand why many teachers find their current station in life to be unenviable.

When one's money is worth relatively less than it used to be, despite putting in the same amount, if not more effort, than before, teachers feel that they are being compensated unfairly given their heavy workload and level of responsibility.

This problem is combined with an ever-increasing demand for teaching, which is usually met with more incentive to enter the vocation in a healthy economy. Unfortunately for teachers, this is not the case.

The effect on the teachers themselves is echoed in the industry. It's clear to see this because the weathering is happening on two fronts at once.

It's bad enough that teachers are resigning more frequently, leaving vacant positions in schools that have doubled in the past two years; this is in addition to a failure to meet the recruitment goals for trainee teachers, which has reached a shockingly low figure of 59% of demand.

Let's look at more specific information. The shortage is mainly in the mathematics and science departments, especially as the subjects become more specialised, i.e. GCSE and A-levels.

If we are to analyse this symptomatically, it seems as if prospective teachers are faced with a choice of taking their advanced skills in maths and science to an academic level or applying them somewhere outside of the teaching industry, both of which are pretty apparently more appealing than receiving comparatively low pay and career mobility teaching their subjects at secondary schools.

To summarise the challenges faced by the teaching sector in the UK: It seems as though the risk-to-reward ratio of teaching as a profession (especially in secondary schools, where the work is the most challenging) is not worth it for many current and prospective teachers, who would instead take their chances with different forms of employment, or even independent tuition which is becoming increasingly popular.

Strategies to Improve Teacher Retention Rates

Before diving into potential strategies to deal with the problems we outlined in the previous section, it's important to note that nothing in this article is a definitive or evidence-based solution to a complicated problem. These ideas are commonly used to increase incentives and recruitment in various contexts.

Increasing Pay

Probably the most straightforward solution to the teaching crisis is to augment teachers' pay as compensation for their work. This solution is already being partially implemented thanks to the recent union-organised teachers strikes, which prompted the government to increase all teachers' salaries by 6.5% prospectively for the 2023/4 academic year.

This solution does not treat the cause of the problems, which is the economic problems of the UK. Still, it certainly does treat the symptoms, making the teaching profession far more bearable depending on the extent of the increase.

Unions continue to organise industrial action with the hopes of obtaining a double-digit increase, but the outcome of such protests has yet to manifest.

Redistributing Pay

A slightly more controversial method of increasing teacher retention rates is to redistribute pay so that the senior positions in schools would not make as much more than the standard positions, which are currently in jeopardy.

The benefit of this strategy is that there is no requirement to further invest in the education sector, which is already proving challenging for the government. It simply requires the current salaries to be re-evaluated so that the difference between the pay of the leadership positions and the basic positions is more minor.

The controversial element is relatively easy to see since the strategy, with no further government spending, would require senior positions to earn less money, meaning that depending on individual factors, specific staff would have to change their lifestyles dramatically. This is perhaps an unfair thing to ask since it isn't the fault of senior teachers that the economy is in such turmoil.

Increasing Opportunities for Teachers

Teaching as an industry might become much more appealing for prospective teachers if there were more opportunities for them to advance in their careers and climb the work ladder.

This could be implemented in several ways, for example, using the additional holiday time that comes with the job to provide optional training for teachers who want to take on additional responsibilities and earn more.

These opportunities exist somewhat, with grants available to teachers who can provide evidence of their efforts to improve and take on challenges. Still, with incentives so low in the profession, it would be nice if the opportunities were more readily available for the teachers who aren't ready to take the initiative themselves.

While the drawbacks of this strategy areare the additional opportunities' cost in both time and money, the benefits are plentiful. Better-trained and more enthusiastic teachers are proven to provide better education and more effective teaching to students, their care, and their colleagues via peer mentoring.

Improved Benefits for Teachers

When it comes to methods for increasing retention outside of direct pay increases and financial incentives, one of the best methods tends to be the benefits package associated with a job.

Benefits can mean almost anything, but the idea with this strategy is to provide teachers with additional privileges and perks that do not necessarily have a significant or direct impact on the education budget while still improving the quality of life and, thus, the retention and recruitment rate of UK teachers.

An example of this might be some form of priority in the healthcare system. Since teachers fulfil a vital role in society and are needed with extremely high demand in recent years, it wouldn't be outlandish to be given a fast track through NHS waiting lists to get them back in the classroom when they fall ill.

The controversy with privileges like this is that they increase the social division between groups. Therefore, it's essential to carefully evaluate the impact of such changes before implementing them. With the healthcare example, for instance, it would be essential to limit the benefit, such as the teacher's priority never superseding emergency care.

Afterword

Thank you for reading our article on the teaching crisis in the UK. If you enjoyed this article and want to read more about teaching as a profession, check out the rest of our related articles here on the Superprof blog. We also have plenty of other articles about many different subjects, so make sure to look around. We hope to see you again soon!