Who is to blame?

In J.B. Priestley's play, "An Inspector Calls", we learn that a number of characters have contributed to the suicide of Eva Smith. Who do you think deserves the most blame and why?

Hi, personally I do not think that one specific individual is to blame, however if you look the idea that every action has a consequence then I would say that Mr Birling is to blame. He was the first person to let Eva down and therefore the chain of events with the rest of the family etc started with him.
02 July 2013
In Priestly's play, An Inspector Calls all of the Birlings and Gerald Croft can be blamed for Eva's death to some extent.  Each of the character's actions contribute to Eva (or Daisy's) eventual suicide.  What is more important is how each of the characters react to the discovery of their actions; the younger characters Sheila and Eric learn from their mistakes but the older characters Mr and Mrs Birling and Gerald (representative of the monied upper classes) feel that their behaviour does not matter if it is not publicly revealed. Priestly implies that there is hope for us as a society if we learn from our mistakes but those in charge tend to be more interested in their own preservation than those of the common man or woman (hence the name Eva Smith).  
29 September 2013
To add to this, link Priestley's socialist views to the messages in his play of social repsonsibility
29 September 2013
Your question would seem to  presume, using the concept of 'blame; here,   a fixed moral universe where what is  right or wrong can be read of a list. Ethics and religious belief  show  us a that humankind has come up with a variety of positions over what is ethical,  or not, so a clear answer might be not possible. Each  observer of this play will portion blame (ie  make a moral judgments) in different ways, I would proffer.
01 October 2013
I feel that the author is trying to get across that every character is to blame no one single character. And how many little things can add up to one huge thing and how you should be responsible for your actions. But if I had to blame one character I would blame Eric as he is the more immature or the characters and he did effectively rape Eva Smith. 
04 October 2013
Add an answer Cancel reply

Similar questions

What is the purpose of literature?

Why is literature important?

One of the chief purposes of literature is a means of exploring what it is to be human. It is also a way of communicating with others about a huge range of ideas and concerns. Put simply, Literature helps us to understand people, societies, events, culture. Many students struggle when it comes to analyzing English literature. It can be difficult to identify and understand the underlying themes behind a text. Here, are some tips to help you improve your English lit analysis.

Did the writer actually intend all the meaning that our teachers make us think about?

There can sometimes be a discrepancy between the writer's intention and what the teacher or students actually reads into a novel or piece of literature however the writer does intend to convey certain meanings and will be aware of audience interpretation, the rest of the interpretation will be up to us as readers. Once the piece of literature is out in the world, it is open to the reader to try to understand it with the information available to us. There are many examples where it is easy to see that writers do in fact create layers of meaning in their texts (the colour red used alongside Curley’s Wife in ‘Of Mice and Men’ is a perfect example of this). This is something that becomes more and more obvious the more you study literature. However, it is completely down to the reader to decide if they should read into a piece of literature or not, that is the beauty of literature, it can have a completely different meaning from one reader to the next, but both readings are equally valid. It is also sometimes the case that authors had to use symbolism to get across their meaning rather than simply saying it, for example, if they were writing in a context that banned their ideology. For example, if you believed that homosexuality was normal in Victorian England, it was much safer to hint about it through symbolism in poetry than to risk your reputation and be branded as a lunatic by simply stating it as a fact.

Reading English literature
Studying English literature requires a deeper analysis of the text. Source: Unsplash

What's the difference between GCSE and A-Level English literature?

The main difference between GCSE and A-Level is the amount of originality that you’re expected to bring to your answers. At A-Level, you are expected to read the texts and come to your own conclusions as to what the writer intended. You are expected to read and engage with critical arguments to get an understanding of the deeper themes of the texts. You will also deal with more mature topics at A-Level (sex, politics, oppression, violence, etc), which makes the subject more engaging. You will be expected to understand more of the social, historical, and political contexts surrounding the making of a work of literature. Your essay writing skills should improve, as will your ability to think about wider issues in relation to what you are reading.

What is your marker looking for in an excellent essay?

The most obvious thing that the marker is looking for is the completion of all the assessment objectives, but this can take the magic away from English Literature. In my opinion, an excellent essay shows you have thought deeply about what the author intended with their writing, and that you have come up with your own opinions rather than simply regurgitating what your teacher has said. It’s all well and good to talk about colour, but an outstanding essay could talk about colour specifically applied to nature, or gender, etc in order to display opinions of the time. Your marker will be looking for the ability to read carefully and deeply, to analyze, and to be able to express your ideas fluently and cogently.  In preparation for your assessments: read and absorb as much as you can. Look over past exam questions, brush up on your vocabulary – all the useful words you’ll need for exams, and practice your writing skills as much as possible. In your coursework, be sure to structure your essays properly and form coherent arguments. Use the text and surrounding criticism; all the information is there for the taking. In an excellent essay, you would need to hit all the Assessment Objectives. These vary from including context, analysis, and correct punctuation and grammar. The essay would need to flow fluently and have a good and clear structure. It is sometimes difficult to prepare for controlled assessments and coursework, however, writing out quotes so you can begin to memorize them. To make your essay stand out, even more, you should research a few critics that can be used in your controlled assessment or coursework.

How do I prepare for my controlled assessments and coursework?

Everybody has their own different ways to prepare for exams. The trick is finding what works best for you. Here are some examples of revision techniques:

  • mind-maps,
  • brief essay plans,
  • cue cards,
  • recording your own notes and playing them back
  • writing out practice essays
  • word association